Skip to main content

The Curious Case of Slumdog Millionaire

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button and Slumdog Millionaire are two of the major movies that fight for the 2009 Oscar glory. When both the films have a considerably good chance of winning at the Oscars here is what I think.
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is an interesting movie which reminded me largely of the 1994 Academy Award winning movie, Forrest Gump. Eric Roth who adapted Forrest Gump is the writer here also. When Gump had its share of comedy to it, Roth has penned a more emotional and dramatic screenplay here. It is not that the movie does not work, the movie works. But then, it falls short of being one really good movie. The short story which the movie is based on has been changed to an extent in this film adaptation. Sadly, the movie is slightly boring for some parts. Yet, what holds this loosely written script is the considerably good execution by director David Fincher. David Fincher has visualised his most emotional movie with care. He has also been able to extract maximum out of his cast. Brad Pitt in the title role has given one of his finest performances. His makeup also deserves special mention. Taraji P. Henson as Benjamin’s mother is also terrific. She also has the backing of a powerfully written character. With an interesting plot and some smart execution watch this curious case once.
Danny Boyle’s Slumdog Millionaire is also an interestingly made film set in the Indian backdrop. The best part of the film is the smartly written screenplay by Simon Beaufoy, based on a not-so-great material (Q & A novel). I don't think the novel which the movie is based on hardly offers anything new! The movie has a perfect blend between the things that happen in the past and present. But then, the narrative turns offers nothing new after the first half an hour. The pace of the movie anyhow works good. The factor which slumdog has and which many or most Indian movies lack is the way the movie has filmed it's actions. The actions happened before the camera in Slumdog and it does not at once have the feel its being played. Yet, certain oddness could be felt in the language at parts.
And personally I felt that the visual look of the film is slightly forced. A more raw feel could have been more effective to the treatment of the film. The strongest point of Slumdog besides the screenplay is the score by A. R. Rahman (who has produced much better music which the Academy hasn't heard) and the brilliant casting of characters by co-director Loveleen Tandan.
The trouble with slumdog is that it is not extraordinary. It provides excitement, thrill and fun but all in the old fashioned way.
To my surprise, I don't feel that both these films are worth of an Academy Award for Best Picture though they are both good efforts.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Nidra

I haven't seen the original version of the film, Nidra, which was directed by Bharathan. But the version his son, Sidharth Bharathan, made was lovable for the way it was made. Nidra is a neat film. It has a writing material well adapted by Sidharth and Santhosh. The dialogues from Santhosh Echikkanam are bang on! Loved the visuals of the film as well but it seemed to have an excess of blue all over it. I wonder if Sameer Thahir did that to cover up for the excess of white that he might have had to  accommodate while shooting on the Red camera. The music and background score of the film sounded well with the film. The editing and sound design were no less good. It did feel as though there where a couple of instances when the footages jumped creating a disturbance for a second or two. But, otherwise the editing by Bavan Sreekumar was just too good. I loved the editing on all those scenes that featured the redish look from Sameer and the scene at the dining table that featur...
Post a Comment
Read more

Kaminey

Vishal Bharadwaj's Kaminey is a classic film targeted at the masses. Vishal Bharadwaj could be a genius. He has handled a movie that could turn out to be a total mess at some other guys hand with great brilliance. He has not only managed to execute the film in style but also taken care of the music, screenplay and dialogues of the film. The plot of Kaminey is simple. The construction of the plot is where Vishal and his team has made the magic. As in a Guy Ritchie film here we travel with one character and then at a point slide over to another. The action as in a Quentin Tarantino movie is gonna come hitting at you as hard as you have ever imagined a Bollywood cinema to be (and the better thing here is that you have very less blood compared to QT)! What makes Kaminey have the class is the the fact that it is truely cinematic. Kaminey is a true film and not a hindi film. Vishal Bharadwaj has been able to communicate with his film very universally with the brilliant dark visual t...
3 comments
Read more

Knowing Stanley

Stanley Winston is popularly known as Stan Winston. He could be called a special effects and visual effects artist or even a creature creator! Stan, who was born on the 7th of April, 1946, died on June 15, 2008. I'm not sure how make people would have bothered to see the end credits roll with the name of Stan. But Stan has made visuals and effects that kept many (including me) at the edge of their seats. Winston had been a frequent collaborator with filmmakers such as Steven Spielberg, and James Cameron. Stan wanted to be an actor. He became a painter, a sculptor and an artist. Everything to him was creating characters that tell stories in films. Stan Winston was a man adored by Steven Spielberg. How could Steven not adore a man who made dinosaurs that shuck the whole world. Stan was the creator of live action dinosaurs in the film, Jurassic Park . He was also the man behind the terrific makeover of Arnold Schwarzenegger in the Terminator series. Stanley has won four academy awards...
3 comments
Read more